LD48h#7 unofficial and pending votes - XOut results and comments

Ludum Dare entry link: XOutFinal

Vote results

Fun: 2.78 (2, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 4)
Innovation: 2.78 (2, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 4)
Production: 3.22 (3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5)
Graphics: 3.89 (3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 5)
Sound: N/A (no votes)

Comments

CalvinFrench: - Fun=3 Innovation=2 Production=5 Graphics=5 Sound=0
OK like super duper production and nice 3D animations, great thought out game mechanic but like. Arrgh, no theme and it's too hard! Well anyhow, still a great game. The darkness of death needs to advance a little more slowly and I think it would be better if up/down could move the camera around a bit so you'd have a better idea hwere you are about to make your omelette. Excellent effort but theme abuse

DrPetter: - Fun=3 Innovation=3 Production=3 Graphics=4 Sound=0
Gah, I can't jump! Seriously though, this could be cool if I was able to make it past the first two or three screens. As I've been saying with other entries: I'm no puzzle gamer, so I have very little patience regarding these types of challenges. I get through the first solid floor thing, but the next one has a huge drop below it that crushes my egg. Anyways, graphics are actually pretty cool despite X-0ut complaining about them all the time during the compo, and the controls are ok even though the actual egg-pushing seems a bit dodgy (what determines if I push the egg or go through it?). Gameplay/puzzle mechanics seem to work as well provided that you're more clever than me.

drZool: - Fun=2 Innovation=3 Production=3 Graphics=3 Sound=0

ErikJohnson: - Fun=3 Innovation=3 Production=3 Graphics=3 Sound=0
Neat puzzle/action game. I think that jump would have made it more playable.

GerryJJ: - Fun=? Innovation=? Production=? Graphics=? Sound=?
Doesn't run (hangs at startup).

JacobGohlke: - Fun= Innovation= Production=

JamesHofmann: Fun=3 Innovation=3 Production=3 Graphics=4 Sound=0
Kind of generic "reach the bottom" platform game, only the mechanics seem pretty minimalistic....annoyingly so, even. I didn't like how it revealed the wrong path only when you got there. But not a bad job either.

JohnCampbell: - Fun=2 Innovation=3 Production=4 Graphics=4 Sound=0
This is rather nicely presented with good graphics, and is smooth and bug free too. The gameplay is an interesting mix between a platformer and a puzzle game and quite fun to play. Unfortunately I found it rather frustrating - the controls make movement harder than it should be, and you really need to be able to see more of the level below you. A few easier levels to start with would be good too - I couldn't get past the second level.
Placeholder - Fun=X Innovation=X Production=X Graphics=X Sound=X

Jolle: - Fun=3 Innovation=3 Production=4 Graphics=4 Sound=0
Where's the growth? I bet everyone is asking that so let's not dwell on it. The game looks good, and it's fun for a while. However, it's a bit frustrating in the way that you sometimes has to die once to find out which way to go.. and when you're out of lives you have to restart from the beginning. These kinds of design was pretty usual 20 years back, but remember, gamers are much more lazy today Except from that a pretty solid entry.

JosephWhite: - Fun= Innovation= Production= Graphics= Sound=
Created errors on startup.

MikeHommel: - Fun=3 Innovation=2 Production=3 Graphics=4 Sound=0
I don't like being killed for guessing wrong (beginning of level 2!), and this is another case of "why limit the lives??" You make me restart every time I die, so why not let me retry all I want? It's also quite awkward sometimes to get the egg where you need it (again beginning of level 2... kept pushing it a pixel too far and leaving it behind). But I think this has real potential to be a real game though if it were polished up and made EASIER! It's quite reminiscent of Rock N' Roll, although frankly it's better.

PhilHassey: - Fun= Innovation= Production= Graphics= Sound=
Crashes on my system

Rale: - Fun=3 Innovation=4 Production=3 Graphics=5 Sound=0
Nice mix of puzzle and action. Time limit made me lose my nerves few times. Espesially there is no unlimited lives. Explosions, character & egg look really great..! No sounds Had to give 3 for production because everything is not done during the contest timelimits. Is the egg supposed to present the growth element ? :/

SMX: - Fun= Innovation= Production= Graphics= Sound=

TomaszDobrowolski2: - Fun= Innovation= Production= Graphics= Sound=

xaver: - Fun=2 Innovation=3 Production=3 Graphics=4 Sound=0
A platform style game where you must roll an egg around without breaking it. This could have been much more fun with the ability to jump. Unfortunately, it's possible to get stuck too easily if you accidentally fall down a block from where the egg was. The graphics are very polished.

Deepflame: - Fun=4 Innovation=2 Production=3 Graphic=3 Sound=0
Hard to determine what theme this game was made for. Looks nice though and plays smooth.